Ccna final exam - java, php, javascript, ios, cshap all in one. This is a collaboratively edited question and answer site for professional and enthusiast programmers. It's 100% free, no registration required.
Friday, May 25, 2012
Will Google Android ever support .NET?
Now that the G1 with Google's Android OS is now available (soon), will the android platform ever support .Net?
Update: Since I wrote this answer two years ago, we productized Mono to run on Android. The work included a few steps: porting Mono to Android, integrating it with Visual Studio, building plugins for MonoDevelop on Mac and Windows and exposing the Java Android APIs to .NET languages. This is now available at http://monodroid.net
Mono on Android is based on the Mono 2.10 runtime, and defaults to 4.0 profile with the C# 4.0 compiler and uses Mono's new SGen garbage collection engine, as well as our new distributed garbage collection system that performs GC across Java and Mono.
The links below reflect Mono on Android as of January of 2009, I have kept them for historical context
Mono now works on Android thanks to the work of Koushik Dutta and Marc Crichton.
You can see a video of it running here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/mono-on-android-with-gratuitous-shaky.html
And you can get the instructions to build Mono yourself here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/building-mono-for-android.html
You can get a benchmark comparing Mono's JIT vs Dalvik's interpreter here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/dalvik-vs-mono.html
And of course, you can get a pre-configured image with Mono here (go to the bottom of the post for details on using that): http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/building-mono-for-android.html
Yes, it will be possible and it won't be that difficult. All what's needed at this point to start with is some kind of converter that will turn MSIL into Dalvik bytecode. Since both formats are open-sourced and well documented, there won't be any problem with it.
So, writing Android applications in C# or VB.NET will be possible, question is how much of .NET framework standard libraries will be supported. But that's another issue.
Oscar Reyes wrote:
I'm pretty sure if google hand ANY interest in .net, they would've design something while Android was in the first stages, not now when they are in production stages. I don't mean it is not possible, what I'm saying is they're not interested. Maybe in mmm hhhh 10 yrs.
Actually what they've already designed is very compatible with Java and .NET
They can't do everything at once, but if you look into Android SDK, there is a tool called dx. This tool converts Java bytecode into Dalvik bytecode, so in other words, you can run programs written in Java on Android with no effort today. Now the same tool is needed for .NET.
Considering how similar .NET and Java are, it's really a matter of time.
ddimitrov wrote:
The .Net->Java->Dalvik translation can be done even now (http://dev.mainsoft.com/), but I think you underestimate the lack of .Net libraries. Of course somebody can port Mono, but it's definitely a non-trivial effort.
No need to port Mono. Android already has VM and some basic API. All what's needed is CIL->Dalvik converter and tiny .NET wrapper for Android API (and maybe some basic implementation of some standard .NET classes). That's it.
Update: .NET already works on Android - you will need product called Monodroid (http://monodroid.net) as stated above.
There is Mono for Android, the .NET framework ported for Android. And there is MonoDroid, a development stack for using C# and the core .NET APIs to develop Android-based applications. MonoDroid Preview 1 has been released a couple of days ago.
MonoDroid is awailable for preview. I think that will bridge the gap. However, MonoDroid could be a costly option for development. Their other development tools costs anywhere between $199 and $4000 (The MonoTouch .. iPhone dev tool ... is priced between $399 and $3999). If people develop apps with these tools, they need a very strong business model to see some returns.
.NET compact framework has been ported to Symbian OS (http://www.redfivelabs.com/). If .NET as a 'closed' platform can be ported to this platform, I can't see any reason why it cannot be done for Android.
.NET and Mono are great environments, with many tools and and excellent skills base of people who know how to use them.
I think Mono has the opportunity to be the mobile cross-platform development environment of choice, seeing as they are the only alternative to Objective-C on the iPhone and should be portable to Android, and .NET is already on Windows Mobile.
I'm really hoping to see a solid implementation of Mono on Android, with wrappers for the Android API as with Monotouch, and would be prepared to pay for it since I'm not in a position to do it myself.
You're more likely to see an Android implementation of Silverlight. Microsoft rep has confirmed that it's possible, vs. the iPhone where the rep said it was problematic.
But a version of the .Net framework is possible. Just need someone to care about it that much :)
But really, moving from C# to Java isn't that big of a deal and considering the drastic differences between the two platforms (PC vs. G1) it seems unlikely that you'd be able to get by with one codebase for any app that you wanted to run on both.
In my opinion, it would be technically possible to convert the CLI Bytecode to Dalvik, and to write wrapper classes for some core features such as Collections, File access, etc., even it would be hard work.
But a .NET desktop application ran on android would feel alien, as it would have a classic Windows-Like GUI which is not very usable on a touch device. If, on the other hand, you were to code an android-like GUI in .NET, you would need another set of wrappers (notice that wrapping is just the other way round opposed to the wrappers mentioned above).
I'm not sure if a .NET mobile application would feel native on android, but I'd guess it wouldn't.
Maybe you're interestend in another approach: You can write your application in the Java language. You can then compile it to .NET via Microsoft J# (I know it's discontinued but you can still download and use it) and use the same Java code on android. Again, that's for the core classes aka business logic and again you would have to write tow GUIs. Maybe you can tages J2ME as well, which you will not be able to do if you use .NET.
.NET for Android seems like a real possibility to me. There is news that Microsoft will release proper Silverlight for Android- Never underestimate the advantages to Microsoft for putting the boot into Apple. A smartphone that is faster, more feature rich, faster development lifecycle, impressive hardware, Flash & Silverlight as a standard installable.
Microsoft has a vested interest in improving Android, and at the same time, applications will be devloped for Silverlight on Android will also work on Windows Phone 7 OS with multi-touch, GPS, etc., etc.
Android is open source, .net is not, they're kind of incompatible in nature ( not technologically but in "philosophy" )
Android has an Apache style license, that mean that anyone can do what they want with the source code, so if there is a group of very inspired and talented geeks, the .net support may be done outside google control in a parallel project. Of course I think none of the coders with enough knowledge, time ( and lets face it money ) will think in start this subproject by them selves and they will focus on current Android development as it is.
Since .net is NOT open source, the integration may be done only under Microsoft sponsorship ( because at difference of Mono, it's not about to create a new JVM -oops I mean CLI- ) Well probably someone think in creating the port.
So although it is human possible , don't expect this will come from Google nor Microsoft. If this ever happen ( and I already say it won't ) it will be from someone as Miguel de Icaza.
Perhaps here is the next ggrrrrreat open source project.
EDIT 22 jan 2009
I was about to eat my own answer but in a second read I can argue that I said:
Not from Google or Microsoft[...] but someone as Miguel de Icaza
And there it is, a few weeks later Miguel providing links about the progress of Mono on Android.
Update: Since I wrote this answer two years ago, we productized Mono to run on Android. The work included a few steps: porting Mono to Android, integrating it with Visual Studio, building plugins for MonoDevelop on Mac and Windows and exposing the Java Android APIs to .NET languages. This is now available at http://monodroid.net
ReplyDeleteGetting Started: http://monodroid.net/Welcome
Documentation: http://monodroid.net/Documentation
Tutorials: http://monodroid.net/Tutorials
Mono on Android is based on the Mono 2.10 runtime, and defaults to 4.0 profile with the C# 4.0 compiler and uses Mono's new SGen garbage collection engine, as well as our new distributed garbage collection system that performs GC across Java and Mono.
The links below reflect Mono on Android as of January of 2009, I have kept them for historical context
Mono now works on Android thanks to the work of Koushik Dutta and Marc Crichton.
You can see a video of it running here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/mono-on-android-with-gratuitous-shaky.html
And you can get the instructions to build Mono yourself here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/building-mono-for-android.html
You can get a benchmark comparing Mono's JIT vs Dalvik's interpreter here: http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/dalvik-vs-mono.html
And of course, you can get a pre-configured image with Mono here (go to the bottom of the post for details on using that): http://www.koushikdutta.com/2009/01/building-mono-for-android.html
Yes, it will be possible and it won't be that difficult. All what's needed at this point to start with is some kind of converter that will turn MSIL into Dalvik bytecode. Since both formats are open-sourced and well documented, there won't be any problem with it.
ReplyDeleteSo, writing Android applications in C# or VB.NET will be possible, question is how much of .NET framework standard libraries will be supported. But that's another issue.
Oscar Reyes wrote:
I'm pretty sure if google hand ANY
interest in .net, they would've design
something while Android was in the
first stages, not now when they are in
production stages. I don't mean it is
not possible, what I'm saying is
they're not interested. Maybe in mmm
hhhh 10 yrs.
Actually what they've already designed is very compatible with Java and .NET
They can't do everything at once, but if you look into Android SDK, there is a tool called dx. This tool converts Java bytecode into Dalvik bytecode, so in other words, you can run programs written in Java on Android with no effort today. Now the same tool is needed for .NET.
Considering how similar .NET and Java are, it's really a matter of time.
ddimitrov wrote:
The .Net->Java->Dalvik translation can
be done even now
(http://dev.mainsoft.com/), but I
think you underestimate the lack of
.Net libraries. Of course somebody can
port Mono, but it's definitely a
non-trivial effort.
No need to port Mono. Android already has VM and some basic API. All what's needed is CIL->Dalvik converter and tiny .NET wrapper for Android API (and maybe some basic implementation of some standard .NET classes). That's it.
Update: .NET already works on Android - you will need product called Monodroid (http://monodroid.net) as stated above.
Miguel de Icaza's announced on his blog on the 17th of Feb 2010 that they are starting work on mono for android which will be called MonoDroid.
ReplyDeleteThis will be similar to MonoTouch on the iphone but for android instead.
It will provide binding to the android UI, so apps will look and feel live native android apps. This will require you to write an android specific UI.
You will however be able to reuse you existing lower level libraries without the need to recompile.
Since this is one of the first links on Google when search for Android and .net support, it is only fitting to post this here.
ReplyDeleteThe mono project is working on a SDK to develop Android applications using CIL languages such as C#. The down side is it will be a commercial product.
http://go-mono.com/monodroid/
There is Mono for Android, the .NET framework ported for Android. And there is MonoDroid, a development stack for using C# and the core .NET APIs to develop Android-based applications. MonoDroid Preview 1 has been released a couple of days ago.
ReplyDeleteMonoDroid is awailable for preview. I think that will bridge the gap. However, MonoDroid could be a costly option for development. Their other development tools costs anywhere between $199 and $4000 (The MonoTouch .. iPhone dev tool ... is priced between $399 and $3999). If people develop apps with these tools, they need a very strong business model to see some returns.
ReplyDeleteCheck this out http://www.xmlvm.org/overview/ . I think this is possible. May be can also check this video http://youtube.com/?v=s8nMpi5-P-I
ReplyDeleteA modified port of Mono is also entirely possible.
ReplyDelete.NET compact framework has been ported to Symbian OS (http://www.redfivelabs.com/). If .NET as a 'closed' platform can be ported to this platform, I can't see any reason why it cannot be done for Android.
ReplyDelete.NET and Mono are great environments, with many tools and and excellent skills base of people who know how to use them.
ReplyDeleteI think Mono has the opportunity to be the mobile cross-platform development environment of choice, seeing as they are the only alternative to Objective-C on the iPhone and should be portable to Android, and .NET is already on Windows Mobile.
I'm really hoping to see a solid implementation of Mono on Android, with wrappers for the Android API as with Monotouch, and would be prepared to pay for it since I'm not in a position to do it myself.
You're more likely to see an Android implementation of Silverlight. Microsoft rep has confirmed that it's possible, vs. the iPhone where the rep said it was problematic.
ReplyDeleteBut a version of the .Net framework is possible. Just need someone to care about it that much :)
But really, moving from C# to Java isn't that big of a deal and considering the drastic differences between the two platforms (PC vs. G1) it seems unlikely that you'd be able to get by with one codebase for any app that you wanted to run on both.
In my opinion, it would be technically possible to convert the CLI Bytecode to Dalvik, and to write wrapper classes for some core features such as Collections, File access, etc., even it would be hard work.
ReplyDeleteBut a .NET desktop application ran on android would feel alien, as it would have a classic Windows-Like GUI which is not very usable on a touch device. If, on the other hand, you were to code an android-like GUI in .NET, you would need another set of wrappers (notice that wrapping is just the other way round opposed to the wrappers mentioned above).
I'm not sure if a .NET mobile application would feel native on android, but I'd guess it wouldn't.
Maybe you're interestend in another approach: You can write your application in the Java language. You can then compile it to .NET via Microsoft J# (I know it's discontinued but you can still download and use it) and use the same Java code on android. Again, that's for the core classes aka business logic and again you would have to write tow GUIs. Maybe you can tages J2ME as well, which you will not be able to do if you use .NET.
.NET for Android seems like a real possibility to me. There is news that Microsoft will release proper Silverlight for Android- Never underestimate the advantages to Microsoft for putting the boot into Apple. A smartphone that is faster, more feature rich, faster development lifecycle, impressive hardware, Flash & Silverlight as a standard installable.
ReplyDeleteMicrosoft has a vested interest in improving Android, and at the same time, applications will be devloped for Silverlight on Android will also work on Windows Phone 7 OS with multi-touch, GPS, etc., etc.
Android is open source, .net is not, they're kind of incompatible in nature ( not technologically but in "philosophy" )
ReplyDeleteAndroid has an Apache style license, that mean that anyone can do what they want with the source code, so if there is a group of very inspired and talented geeks, the .net support may be done outside google control in a parallel project. Of course I think none of the coders with enough knowledge, time ( and lets face it money ) will think in start this subproject by them selves and they will focus on current Android development as it is.
Since .net is NOT open source, the integration may be done only under Microsoft sponsorship ( because at difference of Mono, it's not about to create a new JVM -oops I mean CLI- ) Well probably someone think in creating the port.
So although it is human possible , don't expect this will come from Google nor Microsoft. If this ever happen ( and I already say it won't ) it will be from someone as Miguel de Icaza.
Perhaps here is the next ggrrrrreat open source project.
EDIT 22 jan 2009
I was about to eat my own answer but in a second read I can argue that I said:
Not from Google or Microsoft[...] but someone as Miguel de Icaza
And there it is, a few weeks later Miguel providing links about the progress of Mono on Android.
:)
Shoot me now!!!